I’ve just learned that I am a jerk, by the decided opinion of my two friends here, both of whom grew up in New York City and have lived here most of their lives.
The domain of jerkiness in question is taxi tipping.
My friends (in the course of a conversation that we openly admit constituted a Seinfeld moment) say that the minimum cash taxi tip, under any circumstances, is a dollar.
My own cash tipping policy, which has never before (to my knowledge) gotten me in trouble after hundreds of taxi rides, is as follows:
- For fares over $5, tip 20% or more of the base fare plus tolls and fees, rolling up (above 120%) to a round dollar amount. Add extra dollar(s) for exceptionally attentive service, in the rain, after 11pm or on a holiday, in heavy traffic (especially if the cab will continue to be stuck in it after I get out), if the driver is or I am in a visibly jolly mood, if the driver appears to need a pick-me-up, if music I like is playing, if I’ve stranded the guy in a second-class borough and/or left him pointed in an inconvenient direction, or otherwise at the slightest inclination that the tip as initially calculated doesn’t feel like enough.
- For fares under $5, tip up to the next dollar (e.g., $3.50 becomes $4.00). If very late at night, or the driving seems hard due to weather or traffic, or in other exceptional circumstances, add another dollar.
- Round up to a round dollar amount. Except in rare circumstances, don’t bother handing over coin, and never, ever accept any back. The former is inconvenient for me, and the latter seems petty and rude.
Our story begins when I board a northbound taxi stopped at the light at Church and Barclay, in the left lane. I ask to be taken to Church and Duane, left side, near corner. The alert reader will observe that this is a trip of six short blocks, in a straight line, without even changing lanes.
The fare on the meter at flag pull is $3.50 (the $2.50 base fare, plus the 50-cent night charge, plus the 50-cent New York State “balance the budget on the backs of NYC tourists” surcharge).
Traffic is light and the trip takes about 60 seconds. Just as the taxi is about to stop, as I am extending my hand with a $10 bill in it, the meter jumps to $3.90.
I ask for six dollars back. The driver pauses. “You’re giving me ten cents?”
(It’s worth noting here that today is the wrong day for anyone to get in an argument with me about nothing. Those of you who have kept me company through the challenges of the past week may understand why.)
“It was six blocks in a straight line — in the direction you were already pointed when I got in the cab.”
Grumble grumble.
“You didn’t even have to change lanes! It took us one minute to get here. There’s no ‘service’ to tip for.”
He mumbles something hostile as he hands me the bills, and that sets me off. “Okay, fine. I’ll have the ten cents back, too.”
“I don’t have it. I have a quarter — here you go, now give me fifteen cents.”
I decline the quarter, get out of the cab and walk away, in a hail of grumbling.
Now I get that someone might look at a ten-cent tip and be offended. What I see, though, is that I turned him a full $3.50 fare (with that flag-pull minimum), plus 40 cents’ worth of mileage, in 60 seconds. And all he had to do is keep the wheel straight and step on the gas — he didn’t even have to pull over to pick me up! And it’s a Friday night in Tribeca, there are fares all over the place. He probably had another in the cab in 30 seconds.
What say you: am I a jerk?