I have to admit that I’m of two minds on last night’s NYPD clearing of Zuccotti Park, the birthplace of the Occupy movement — which happens to be three short blocks from my apartment building.
Obviously (and in case it isn’t obvious, I’ll say it) I support the movement. I’ve gone from being one of those mildly curious “what are their demands?” people to being impressed by the extent to which this movement has made inequality a legitimate subject for serious public debate — for the first time in a generation. So, good on them.
But as someone who lives close enough that I was awakened at 2am today by helicopters and sirens, and that people were arrested in the early morning hours at a police line right at the end of my street, well — I’m not so sure an indefinite and semi-organized domination of a public space by a loud and intimidating (yes, intimidating) band of grubby, confrontational people is something you’d want in your neighborhood. People live down here. For weeks I’ve avoided turning left at the end of my block instead of right, because going left just wasn’t worth the anxiety. And I’m a six-foot-two man, sympathetic to the occupiers, and someone who, in ordinary circumstances, isn’t much bothered by anything or anyone.
Bloomberg’s been in an impossible position for weeks — not because of his “girlfriend” or his “cronies,” but because even a liberal mayor (which, duh, have you ever paid attention to anything the guy has said?) is obligated to protect public order for everyone. There are times when “public order” is a cover for an anti-idealistic crackdown, but this isn’t one of them. Camping on private property without the consent of the owner is in clear violation of the law. (If it were a public park, the violation would be even clearer.) And when an EMT doing his job is assaulted, you’ve reached a point where public order has broken down.
The media blackout was a terrible idea, and is being rightly treated as such in the public debate. But I suspect a silent majority of Occupy’s supporters — and certainly of the hundreds of thousands who live and work in lower Manhattan — are ready for the next phase of the Occupy movement. The Zuccotti occupation has achieved what it needed to.