Tonight we’re watching “So You Think You Can Dance,” tape-delayed from last night. It’s the top 11, this time paired with “all-stars” from previous seasons.

I like SYTYCD because it involves genuine talent, of a type that you can’t fake. Creativity and innovation count for something here, but you also need native ability and the willingness to learn and hone a craft. These young people aren’t just putting one over on America — on “America’s Got Talent,” a schlocky ventriloquist might make it to Vegas, but you’re not going to crack the top 20 on SYTYCD unless you’re a star across the board. And you won’t survive elimination unless you keep up your game.
Now, when I first came to this show, I knew almost nothing about dance — possibly even less than you do. But after three seasons of this — and the judges, though they have their quirks, are pretty dedicated and legit — I’ve learned a lot about both how to recognize good dance and how to enjoy it.
On the whole, the contestants’ partners (the all-stars) were visibly better than the contestants — smoother, snappier, cleaner, more effortless. The contrast was obvious, for example, in Melinda’s and Pasha’s routine. Even when they were doing the same step side by side, your eyes were mostly on him. But Robert’s and Courtney’s African jazz routine was an exception. He matched her move for move, and brought a grace and a bounce and a flexibility and a confidence of his own. Nigel called him a dark horse, but I think he’s going to turn out to be more than that — he’s the one to beat. It’s on!
Kent, in his cha cha, wasn’t the best ballroom dancer I’ve ever seen. But wow! I can’t remember when I’ve seen a dancer having so much fun. And isn’t that the whole point?
One final comment: for two of these dancers, Alex and Robert, this was probably the best day of their entire lives. Look at their faces as the judges give their notes! Aside from everything else, the humanity of this show is what gets me.
Straight recap here. Bitchier recap, with video links, here.